Rosemary Nissen-Wade: Aussie poet and teacher of metaphysics – a personal view
My bestie nicknamed me SnakyPoet on her blog, and I liked it. (It began as
'the poet of the serpentine Northern Rivers' and became more and more abbreviated.)
If your comment doesn't immediately appear: Please note, I've been forced to moderate comments to discourage spam. As I live Down Under in the Southern Hemisphere, those of you Up Top might have to wait a while to see your comments appear. I may well be asleep when you read and post. Don't panic, nothing's gone wrong and you don't need to do anything – just wait. ______________________________________________________________

Sunday, January 15, 2023

I wish everyone would read this - not just quote from it.














Spare - My review (also on Amazon and GoodReads)


I wish people would read it all, with an open mind, rather than merely the sensationalised sound bites and misinterpretations. Unfortunately we live in an era when people are conditioned to want and believe the sound bites and the skewed interpretations of them, the more sensational the better.


Harry, the supposed ‘thicko’, has shown himself in recent years to be an articulate, thoughtful man. It is the same with this book. OK, this is ghost-written, but it’s still done from his own account, put together using his own thoughts and words.


He tells it like it is, as he sees it and has experienced it. That’s as close to honesty as any of us can get. (I recently wrote a memoir of my own, so I appreciate the difficulties.) Having lately read ‘Courtiers’ by Valentine Low (an author who is said to hold no great brief for Harry and Meghan) I can readily believe the many machinations that go on behind the scenes by staffers and bureaucrats from various royal households scheming to sway the press favourably towards their own principals, even at the cost of blatant untruths. Harry hasn't told the half of it!


Even so, I was shocked to learn how many of the things I’ve read over the years have been outright lies - even things not especially nasty, but nevertheless completely made up so as to have and sell a story.


By now - indeed, from early on - Harry and Meghan can’t win; for most of the press and social media, whatever they do or say, it’s wrong. That’s already the case with this book too. The outrage is already being confected. The book is selling well - but an even larger public, I think, is put off reading it at all because of what they have already been fed about this couple, and/or because of believing the spin put on the bits taken out of context. To be fair, the book does include allegations which appear to be justly deserved, and which have only been made now as a very last resort.


It may be true, as some people are saying, that it was naive of him to write it. But keeping silent over the years didn’t do any good either. I understand his wish to get his truth out there: his own knowledge, feelings and recollections. I even applaud him for it.


I only hope that, whatever people’s reactions, this couple may be able to find both the peace they crave for themselves and their children, and the work they want to do. In fact, they seem to be making some headway in both respects, despite serious challenges, since their move away from Britain. I think the troubles that befell them since their relationship began are no fault of their own, and they have earned the right to thrive.



Note: I listened to it as an audio book (read by Harry) simultaneously with reading the ebook.

19 comments:

  1. Actually Span, but couldn't be bothered going through all the log-in folderol - in all of this recent hoopla I don't think I've heard anyone reasonably address what should be the bleeding obvious: the tragic obliteration (death too mild a word here) of his mother is not something he is prepared to live quietly and comfortably with. The media loves to make a circus of the royals, and to some extent they ask for it, and I am sure he knew what he was letting himself in for here. My own opinion - which is no more than an opinion - is that he was certainly naive to make yet another public statement (i.e. this book) and silence would be preferable. But he has chosen to take responsibility for his own decisions, as everyone has the right to do.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've just finished listening to it and couldn't agree more. I think the media is acting as though they are impartial and as though the main complaints are about the royal family, when of course it's the family-as-business-entity plus the media thats the target.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This one was posted on fb before I asked people to post here instead:

    Shae Brown
    Excellent Review Rosemary. I haven't read it yet but had the same response to the series on Netflix. It's so easy to armchair judge, without careful investigation or consideration. Many such judgements are guilty of the same discriminatory behaviour H & M experienced in the Royal household.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very well said, an excellent review. I have seen some savage comments in book groups. Sad that there is so little empathy toward those having to live in the lime light, hiding their pain for many years.

    ReplyDelete
  5. And another who missed the veto:

    Evi Schumacher
    Haven’t read it, but listening to his interview with Stephen Colbert. It took a lot of guts to speak out and leave himself vulnerable to the media vultures.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Evi Schumacher17/01/2023, 05:42

      Thank you, Rosemary, I guess I tried to fix it too late. :-)

      Delete
  6. Perhaps it won't surprise you to know we are perfectly aligned on everything you say here – everything!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I watched his interview on Colbert. Apart from seeing that he was traumatized by living in a very dysfunctional family - which happened to be more strongly devoted to their ceremonial roles and keeping "the firm" in business, than to "family values" in a more traditional sense ... it seemed evident to me that he is one of the smarter members of that family (just as Colbert is smarter than most late-night hosts). I'm hoping that the Brits will just give up on having a hereditary monarchy, it's ridiculous and retrograde.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Nah, that doesn't surprise me at all haaaa.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for this, Rosemary. I haven't read it yet but I have certainly seen Harry making the US talk show rounds. He seems sincere and I'm inclined to believe much of what he and Meghan have been saying. I like them, but I sometimes feel it's all a bit too much, that these entitled people are whining about being so mistreated, while my wife and I are striving to help support a young family in Ukraine who literally are fearing for their lives every single day. We need to put our "first-world problems" in perspective. I tried watching the Netflix miniseries but frankly lost interest after the seond episode. I think now that the book is out, they need to step out of the limelight for a while and let things settle. I doubt things will ever be the same between them and the rest of the Royal family again.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A quote from the Australian public broadcaster (i.e. a calm, trsutworthy source): You may think you know everything there is to know about Prince Harry's book, Spare.
      You may feel there's no need to pick up a copy, because you've heard it all, seen it all, even reacted to it all in the week since it's been published. Think again.
      It's one thing to read a bunch of news articles summing up the story. It's quite another to read (or listen to) the story yourself.

      Delete
  10. I may have to read this when the hoopla dies down a bit more, by which point my own To Be Read Pile might have been better tamed.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Meg Oldman
    Brilliant review, Rosemary!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Ina Roy-Faderman
    Just read your review, as well as Sharyn's comment. Sounds right on to me.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks Rosemary. I enjoyed your review and concur.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Dear Rosemary - a sane and sensible and compassionate review - I too have seen only interviews and the Netflix series and agree with your sentiments. I shall read the book as well and I do concur that the unrelenting pressure of the British press combined with the trauma of a beloved mother’s excruciating loss entitles, Harry, as well as any human being so besieged and unprotected to offer the narrative and reclamation of hos own life. Thank you again for a brilliant review.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Whoops! Apologies for my failure to sign my comment as posted above !

      Delete
  15. Brianna Rae
    I really agree xx I respect him for the hard work of going through the enormously hard task of seeing one’s upbringing and relatives in a more sobering light, stepping away from them to forge a new life in a new country/culture with his own set of values formed in response to what he’s gone through. A transformation of a life, of a psyche, and he invites us to take the same journey. He could have done it quietly but he wants to defend his name, his wife, the name of his children and I don’t blame him for doing it publically.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Jim Youngman
    See: https://www.abc.net.au/.../spare-by-prince.../101857156

    ReplyDelete

Comments are moderated and will be visible after approval from blog owner. If you can only comment anonymously, please include your name in the comment, just so I know who's talking to me.